I’m really not concerned with what you personally believe, but I think that what you assert to others IS important. My hope was that having explained my concerns with your public position on user stories, you might consider some changes.

While certainly different, I don’t consider our perspectives contrary. I think each of our perspectives might benefit from consideration of the other.

For example, your perspective has made me more aware of the differences between describing the job to be done and specifying the requirements. That’s useful, and I appreciate the distinction.

I wish you all the best in your pursuit of excellence.